Article acceptance requirements
The criteria for an article to be accepted for publication include:
- The article should be original writing that enhances the existing body of knowledge in the given subject area. Original review articles and surveys are acceptable, even if new data/concepts are not presented.
- Results reported have not been submitted or published elsewhere (although expanded versions of conference publications are eligible for submission).
- Experiments, statistics, and other analyses are performed to a high technical standard and are described in sufficient detail.
- Conclusions are presented in an appropriate fashion and are supported by the data.
- The article is presented in an intelligible fashion.
- Appropriate references to related prior published works must be included.
Checklist for preparing your paper for publication
You can use this list to carry out a final check of your submission before you send it to the journal for review.
- Is your manuscript adhere to the minimum standards? (the length of the submitted paper is at least 4 pages and no more than 16 pages; use a tool such as EndNote, Mendeley, or Zotero for reference management and formatting, and choose IEEE style)
- Is your manuscript written in JDMIS format? At this stage, it is essential that you follow every detail of the JDMIS format. Please try to follow the format as closely as possible.
- Is your title adequate and is your abstract correctly written? The title of the paper is maxed 15 words, without Acronyms or abbreviations. The Abstract (MAX 200 WORDS) should be informative and completely self-explanatory (no citation in the abstract), provide a clear statement of the problem, the proposed approach or solution, and point out major findings and conclusions.
- Authors are suggested to present their articles in the structure of the sections: Introduction (PENDAHULUAN) - The Proposed Method/Algorithm/Procedure specifically designed (optional) - Research Method (METODE PENELITIAN) - Results and Discussion (HASIL DAN PEMBAHASAN) – Conclusion (KESIMPULAN). Authors may present complex proofs of theorems or non-obvious proofs of the correctness of algorithms after the introduction section (obvious theorems & straightforward proofs of existing theorems are NOT needed).
- Introduction section (PENDAHULUAN): explain the context of the study and state the precise objective. An Introduction should contain the following three parts:
- Background: Authors have to make clear what the context is. Ideally, the authors should give an idea of the state-of-the-art field the report is about.
- The Problem: If there were no problem, there would be no reason for writing a manuscript, and definitely no reason for reading it. So, please tell readers why they should proceed with reading. Experience shows that for this part a few lines are often sufficient.
- The Proposed Solution: Now and only now! - authors may outline the contribution of the manuscript. Here authors have to make sure readers point out what are the novel aspects of the author's work.
Authors should place the paper in the proper context by citing relevant papers. At least, 10 references (recent journal articles) are used in this section.
- Method section (METODE PENELITIAN): the presentation of the experimental methods should be clear and complete in every detail facilitating reproducibility by other scientists.
- Results and discussion section (HASIL DAN PEMBAHASAN): The presentation of results should be simple and straightforward in style. This section reports the most important findings, including results of statistical analyses as appropriate and comparisons to other research results. Results given in figures should not be repeated in tables. This is where the author(s) should explain in words what he/she/they discovered in the research. It should be clearly laid out and in a logical sequence. This section should be supported by suitable references.
- Conclusion section (KESIMPULAN): Summarize sentences the primary outcomes of the study in a paragraph. Are the claims in this section supported by the results, do they seem reasonable? Have the authors indicated how the results relate to expectations and to earlier research? Does the article support or contradict previous theories? Does the conclusion explain how the research has moved the body of scientific knowledge forward?
- Language. If an article is poorly written due to grammatical errors, it may make it more difficult to understand the science.
- Please be sure that the manuscript is up to date. It is expected that 20 to 30% of references are to recent papers.
- Is the manuscript clearly written? Is the article exciting? Does the content flow well from one section to another? Please try to keep your manuscript on the proper level. It should be easy to understand by well-qualified professionals, but at the same time please avoid describing well-known facts (use proper references instead). Often manuscripts receive negative reviews because reviewers are not able to understand the manuscript and this is the authors' (not the reviewers') fault. Notice, that if reviewers have difficulties, other readers will face the same problem and there is no reason to publish the manuscript.
- Do you have enough references? We will usually expect a minimum of 15 to 30 references primarily to journal papers, depending on the length of the paper. Citations of textbooks should be used very rarely and citations to web pages should be avoided. All cited papers should be referenced within the text of the manuscript.
- Figures and Tables. Relation of Tables or Figures and Text: Because tables and figures supplement the text, all tables and figures should be referenced in the text. Avoid placing figures and tables before their first mention in the text. Authors also must explain what the reader should look for when using the table or figure. Focus only on the important point the reader should draw from them, and leave the details for the reader to examine on her own.
a. All figures appearing in the article must be numbered in the order they appear in the text.
b. Each figure must have a caption fully explaining the content
c. Figure captions are presented as a paragraph starting with the figure number i.e. Figure 1, Figure 2, etc.
d. Figure captions appear below Figure
e. Each figure must be fully cited if taken from another article
f. All figures must be referred to in the body of the article
a. Material that is tabular in nature must appear in a numbered captioned table.
b. All tables appearing in the article must be numbered in the order they appear in the text.
c. Each table must have a caption fully explaining the content with the table number i.e. Table 1, Table 2, etc.
d. Each column must have a clear and concise heading
e. Tables are to be presented with a single horizontal line under: the table caption, the column headings, and at the end of the table.
f. All tables must be referred to in the body of the article
g. Each table must be fully cited if taken from another article
- Each citation should be written in the order of appearance in the text in square brackets. For example, the first citation , the second citation , and the third and fourth citations [3,4]. When citing multiple sources at once, the preferred method is to list each number separately, in its own brackets, using a comma or dash between numbers, as such: , , , or [4-8]. It is not necessary to mention an author's name, pages used or date of publication in the in-text citation. Instead, refer to the source with a number in a square bracket, e.g. , that will then correspond to the full citation in your reference list. Examples of in-text citations:
- This theory was first put forward in 1970 ."
- Sutikno  has argued that...
- Several recent studies , , [11-15] have suggested that...
- ...end of the line for my research .
- Self-citations: to control for citation manipulation (COPE, 2019), this journal asks that authors keep self-citation to a minimum. We would strongly recommend no more than 5 (including jointly authored publications), or 20% self-citations, whichever number is lower.
- Please be aware that for the final submission of a regular paper, you will be asked to tailor your paper so the last page is not half empty.